Tuesday, July 24, 2012

Q: Why don't we see green stars?

Stars are black bodies in thermal equilibrium (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black-body_radiation). Their spectrum depends only on their temperature, and the shape of the spectrum is described by Planck's law (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planck%27s_law).
(from http://xkcd.com/54/, showing the spectrum of the cosmic microwave background radiation)

As a result, only some colors are possible: the ones that can be formed by a black-body radiator with this shape of spectrum. The line in the CIE diagram below shows the possible colors of black-body radiation, depending on the temperature:

(from Wikipedia's http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:PlanckianLocus.png)

You will see essentially the same colors from incandescent light bulbs and toaster heating elements as from a star -- a 2700K tungsten filament will radiate light that appears to the human eye with the color corresponding to 2700K on the above diagram.

The "black body" curve does not go through anything you could really call green. 

Qualitatively, for something to appear green, it essentially needs to stimulate the medium-wavelength cones more than the long- and short-wavelength cones in the human eye. Black-body radiation is too broadband to do this.

Here, the colored lines represent the sensitivities of the three kinds of cones in the human eye. The dashed line is black-body radiation from a 5400K star, obeying Planck's law. Black-body radiation is way too broad to hit the "green" cones without also hitting the "red" and "blue" ones. That's why this light appears white.

1 comment:

  1. That was the best and the funniest article on the science that I read. I really got the sight on the first picture and then I kept on reading till the end. Brilliant one.